Embedded YouTube Videos vs Video Tags: Choosing the Right Option for Your Website

In the fast-paced and visually-oriented world of online engagement, leveraging the captivating potential of videos on your website has become essential for visitors and creating an immersive user experience that sets you apart from the competition. When displaying videos on your website, you have two popular options: embedded YouTube videos or video tags. In this article, we will explore each method's advantages and considerations to help you decide which option is best suited for your website.

Embedded YouTube Videos

Embedded YouTube videos involve borrowing content from the YouTube platform and displaying it directly on your website. Embedded YouTube videos provide a convenient and popular way to showcase video content on your website. You can seamlessly integrate videos into your web pages by utilising the embed feature provided by YouTube. 

Advantages of using Embedded Youtube Videos

  1. Seamless Viewing Experience: When you embed a YouTube video on your website, visitors can watch the video without being redirected to the YouTube platform. This creates a seamless viewing experience, keeping users engaged and reducing their likelihood of leaving your site. By keeping visitors on your website, you have a better chance of delivering your message effectively and encouraging them to explore other areas of your site.
  2. Customisation Options: YouTube provides various customisation options for embedded videos. You can adjust the video's dimensions, autoplay settings, and player controls to fit the design and layout of your website. This allows you to maintain a consistent brand experience and create a visually appealing video player that aligns with your website's aesthetics.
  3. Enhanced Search Engine Visibility: as the owner of YouTube, Google favors embedded videos in search results. When you embed a YouTube video on your website and optimise it with relevant keywords, you increase the chances of your video being indexed and appearing in search engine results pages (SERPs). This can significantly improve the visibility of your video content and drive more organic traffic to your website.
  4. Built-in Features and Analytics: YouTube offers a range of built-in features that can enhance the user experience and provide valuable insights. These features include captions, annotations, and end screens, allowing you to add context, call-to-action buttons, and links to your videos. YouTube also provides detailed analytics, allowing you to track the performance of your videos, including views, engagement metrics, and audience demographics.

Disadvantages of using Embedded Youtube Videos

  1. Limited control: When you embed YouTube videos on your website, you relinquish control over the content that appears alongside your video. YouTube may display ads or suggested videos, which can divert viewers' attention away from your intended message or call to action. This lack of control over the surrounding content can potentially impact the overall user experience and dilute the impact of your video.
  2. Reliance on the external platform: Embedding videos from YouTube means your website's video content depends on the YouTube platform's availability and stability. If the video you have embedded is removed or becomes unavailable for any reason, it will result in a broken embed on your website. This can be frustrating for visitors who encounter a video that cannot be played and may leave a negative impression of your website or brand.
  3. Potential slow loading times: Embedding videos can sometimes contribute to slower page load times, especially if the video file or player is large and requires significant bandwidth to load. Slow loading times can harm user experience, as visitors may become impatient and navigate away from your website before the video can play. Optimising video file sizes and implementing techniques to improve loading speed can help mitigate this issue.

Video Tags

The HTML5 video tag allows you to host videos directly on your website's server. Video tags, implemented with HTML5, provide an alternative method for displaying videos on your website. Instead of relying on external platforms like YouTube, you host the video files directly on your server. 

Advantages of using Video Tags 

  1. Full Control over Content: Hosting videos using video tags gives you complete control over your video content. You can upload and manage the videos on your server, ensuring they are always available and under your supervision. This level of control is beneficial for sensitive or proprietary content that you may not want to host on a third-party platform.
  2. Customisation and Branding: Video tags offer flexibility in customisation and branding. You can design the video player to match your website's style, including the player controls, dimensions, and appearance. This allows you to create a cohesive visual experience and maintain a consistent brand presence across your website.
  3. Reduced Distractions: Unlike embedded YouTube videos, video tags eliminate the risk of ads or suggested videos appearing alongside your content. This ensures that viewers' attention remains focused solely on your video without any external distractions. It can be particularly valuable if you want to provide your audience with a seamless and uninterrupted viewing experience.
  4. Technical Considerations: There are a few technical considerations to consider when using video tags. Firstly, different web browsers may support various video formats and codecs, so you must ensure your video files are compatible with a wide range of browsers and devices. Additionally, hosting videos on your server may require additional storage space and bandwidth, impacting website performance and costs. It's essential to optimise your videos for web delivery to minimise loading times and ensure a smooth playback experience.
  5. Search Engine Visibility: Unlike embedded YouTube videos that receive preferential treatment in search results, videos hosted with video tags may have reduced visibility in search engines. Search engines typically prioritise videos from popular platforms like YouTube and Vimeo. However, you can still improve the searchability of your videos by optimising the surrounding text and metadata and using schema markup to provide search engines with relevant information about your videos.

Disadvantages of using Video Tags 

  1. Increased hosting requirements: Hosting videos on your server demands significant storage space and consumes additional bandwidth. Large video files can quickly escalate the hosting costs, particularly if you have high traffic on your website. Moreover, excessive bandwidth usage can lead to slower loading times and reduced website performance. Careful consideration of your hosting resources and budget is crucial before opting for this approach.
  2. Compatibility challenges: Unlike YouTube, where videos are automatically transcoded to various formats for seamless playback on different devices and browsers, hosting videos on your server requires you to manually manage different video formats and codecs. This can be technically demanding and time-consuming. Ensuring compatibility across various web browsers, operating systems, and devices can be challenging, potentially leading to a less consistent viewing experience for your audience.
  3. Reduced search visibility: One of the significant advantages of embedding YouTube videos is the enhanced search engine visibility they enjoy. YouTube, the second-largest search engine after Google, offers better chances of ranking higher in search results. On the other hand, videos hosted with the HTML5 video tag on your website may not receive a different level of visibility. Your video's reach and potential organic traffic from search engines might be limited.

In a Nutshell

Despite the benefits and disadvantages when deciding between embedding videos or hosting them on your server, it's essential to weigh the benefits of convenience and ease of use with the potential drawbacks of limited control, reliance on external platforms, and potential performance implications. Consider your goals, resources, and the desired user experience to determine the most suitable approach for integrating videos on your website.

Both embedded YouTube videos and video tags offer unique benefits and considerations. When deciding which option to choose, consider factors such as user experience, customisation needs, search visibility, and your website's technical capabilities. Embedded YouTube videos are a strong choice if you prioritise a seamless viewing experience, easy customisation, and improved searchability. 

On the other hand, if you require complete control over the content, no external distractions, and are willing to manage the hosting requirements, video tags might be the better option for you. Ultimately, the decision depends on your specific website goals, technical capabilities, and the preferences of your target audience. Whichever method you choose, focus on delivering high-quality, engaging video content that aligns with your website strategy.

How much is a great User Experience worth to you?

Browsee helps you understand your user's behaviour on your site. It's the next best thing to talking to them.

Browsee Product